Article: Calling CFOs: Parcel Spend Management Leakage is Impacting Your Bottom Line

Attention, CFOs! Your company's bottom line might be silently suffering, and we have the numbers to prove it.

In the age of e-commerce, parcel shipping has become an essential component of business operations. However, the most recent Pitney Bowes Parcel Shipping Index reveals a concerning financial reality: despite U.S. parcel volumes decreasing by 2% in 2022, parcel carrier revenues were up by 6.5% year over year. The culprit? Hidden surcharges and accessorial fees are causing significant spend leakage and negatively impacting the financial health of companies nationwide.

Parcel Spend Management Leakage is Impacting Your Bottom Line

Spend Leakage Figures

Consider these annual spend leakage figures Sendflex uncovered during a review of a customer’s carrier invoices:

  • Address corrections: $352,000
  • Residential adjustments: $298,000
  • Dimensional weight adjustments: $2,432,000
  • Oversize adjustments: $321,000
  • Incorrect use of service level: $3,477,000

In this blog, we'll examine these parcel shipping industry trends, analyze the financial implications of hidden surcharges, and reveal how CFOs can leverage parcel orchestration systems to combat spend leakage and protect their bottom line.

Parcel Spend Leakage - More Than a Logistics Problem

While parcel spend leakage may seem like an issue limited to logistics departments, CFOs should be aware that the impacts go far beyond that. In reality, parcel spend leakage is a financial control problem that can have significant consequences for a company's margins and profitability. Unexpected costs that stem from hidden surcharges and accessorial fees eat away at profit margins, making it crucial for financial controllers to recognize the problem and proactively work to resolve it.

To put it into perspective, imagine the cost of raw materials fluctuating wildly without any changes in cost accounting or forecasting. The consequences would be devastating to a company’s stability and would likely result in inaccurate budgeting and forecasting.. Similarly, parcel spend leakage creates a financial blind spot, leaving shippers vulnerable to unanticipated expenses that erode profits.

CFOs must acknowledge that optimizing parcel shipping spend is not merely a logistics issue—it's a crucial financial concern that demands attention from the highest levels of management.

Unexpected Costs That Increase Parcel Spend Leakage

1620080_SendflexBlogGraphic-CallingCFOs_041823 (1)

Historically, companies relied on a single primary parcel carrier to handle their parcel volumes, with minimal rate variance or capacity-related service disruptions. With the boom of e-commerce and an increased reliance on B2C home delivery, however, shippers must now manage a broad portfolio of carriers with different capabilities and rate structures. This makes parcel shipping management more complex than ever. Unexpected costs in the form of surcharges and accessorial fees can dramatically increase overall parcel spend and erode profit margins. The top contributors to parcel spend leakage include:

Address Corrections

Address correction surcharges apply when the address on a parcel package does not match what a carrier’s system determines it should be. They can cost as much as $21.00 per correction for standard package service – and over $100 per correction for express and expedited services. Making matters worse are shippers incurring recurring address corrections for the same delivery address. These surcharges are common and often go unnoticed on carrier invoices, but they are easily avoidable with an intelligent parcel shipping system that utilizes a carrier's unique address validation format to ensure the correct address is printed on shipping labels.

Residential Adjustments

Residential surcharges, which can be as high as $5.80 for ground deliveries, are extra fees levied for deliveries to residential locations. While these charges are largely unavoidable, they should be anticipated and accounted for in the true landed costs of delivery prior to shipping. Advanced parcel shipping systems use location intelligence to correctly determine the type of location, helping shippers plan and budget for residential costs and minimize surprise charges.

Oversize Adjustments

An oversize charge is applied when an individual package exceeds a carrier’s permitted weight or size limits. The specific dimension limits vary by the carrier with surcharges between $95 - $135 per package. Companies can avoid oversize surcharges by splitting larger shipments whenever possible or, when shipping a single large item, accounting for the charges in the final landed costs. Parcel orchestration systems can further minimize these occurrences with embedded business rules that disqualify a carrier service if shipments exceed dimension parameters.

Uncontrolled Service Level Use

Premium carrier services like expedited and express shipping have become integral to many companies’ fulfillment strategies, but are they always necessary?

Depending on a package’s origin and destination, standard ground services can achieve the same result as a premium service, at a lower price point. Intelligent parcel shipping systems use routing rules to enforce cost-effective carrier service selections and minimize spend leakage attributed to unnecessary premium services.

Dimensional Weight Adjustments

Carriers calculate shipping charges based on dimensional (DIM) weight to maximize the cubic space utilization of their vehicles. To prevent rate adjustments, intelligent parcel shipping systems use cartonization algorithms to determine the most transportation-cost-effective way to pack orders, minimizing wasted space. Below we present a case study of dimensional weight adjustments and their financial impacts.

Case Study: The Costs of Unexpected Dimensional Weight Adjustments

Dimensional weight (DIM) adjustments occur when carriers charge shipping fees based on a package's dimensional weight instead of its actual weight. This allows carriers to maximize the cubic space utilization of their vehicles and maintain profitability. When companies do not properly account for DIM weight, they can face unexpected costs, negatively impacting their bottom line. In this case study, we will examine the impact of unanticipated dimensional weight adjustments on Company X, which spends $20 million in parcel spend annually.

Background

Company X is a large e-commerce business that offers free shipping to meet customer expectations and maintain a competitive position in the e-commerce market. With $20 million in annual parcel spend, they have a complex and extensive shipping operation. However, they are not utilizing an intelligent parcel shipping system to optimize their packaging and shipping processes, leading to a significant number of unexpected dimensional weight adjustments.

The Problem

Due to inefficient packaging methods and a lack of proper planning, 10% of Company X's parcel spend – roughly $2 million – is attributed to unexpected dimensional weight adjustments. Since they offer free shipping, these costs cannot be recovered from their customers. Consequently, this unanticipated expense directly impacts their profitability and erodes their margins, ultimately affecting shareholder value.

The Pain Chain

  1. Lack of financial control: Company X's failure to account for dimensional weight adjustments and optimize packaging processes results in a lack of financial control over parcel spend. Without an intelligent parcel shipping system in place, they are unable to effectively monitor and manage these costs.
  2. Profitability hit: The $2 million in unexpected dimensional weight adjustments directly impacts Company X's bottom line, reducing their overall profitability.
  3. Shareholder value: As profitability declines, shareholder value is negatively affected, leading to potential long-term consequences for the company's growth and stability.

The Solution

To address this issue, Company X should implement an intelligent parcel shipping system that utilizes cartonization algorithms and automation to optimize packaging and shipping processes. By minimizing wasted space and ensuring the most cost-effective packaging methods are implemented, the company can significantly reduce the incidence of unexpected dimensional weight adjustments.

Protect Your Profitability with an Intelligent Parcel Spend Management System

The complexity of modern parcel shipping management, coupled with the increased prevalence of unexpected surcharges and accessorial fees, can significantly impact a company's profitability and shareholder value. To mitigate the risks associated with parcel spend leakage, it is crucial for CFOs to engage with logistics departments and take proactive measures to optimize parcel shipping spend.

An intelligent parcel spend management system can reduce total parcel spend by minimizing unexpected surcharges, identifying lowest-cost shipping options, and capturing carrier billing discrepancies. Sendflex helps companies take back financial control with a comprehensive parcel shipping system designed to optimize shipping processes and eliminate unnecessary spend leakage.

Don't let unexpected parcel shipping costs erode your company's profit margins. Request a consultation with us today and secure the financial stability and growth your business deserves.

LEARN

Download
The Five Parcel TMS
Value Pillars

EBOOK

Learn why controlling costs, capacity, carbon, and customer experiences matters in the B2C delivery economy

Shippers who are used to relying on a primary parcel carrier with unlimited capacity must now manage a broader portfolio of carriers, all with different capabilities, performance records, constraints, and rate structures.